Showing posts with label Tebow. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Tebow. Show all posts

Monday, December 24, 2012

Steelers' Playoff Hopes Dead After Loss to Bengals; Trade Roethlisberger for Kirk Cousins?

By Finesse

The Steelers' season came to a fitting end yesterday after a game full of sustained incompetence, inexplicable coaching, and a legacy-impacting stink bomb from Big Ben.  We will have full analysis on our podcast tonight, but here are a few quick thoughts.


- Roethlisberger emptied his entire arsenal of "This one's on me" after the game yesterday, and that's how it should be.  Not only was he mediocre during his best moments yesterday, but looming over him the entire game was the one question that, when lingering, is often the kiss of death for quarterbacks: when is the backbreaking interception coming?

First quarter:


And moments before the interception on the game-losing 4th quarter drive:

Gone are the days when you could arguably include Roethlisberger in the discussion of "which QB do I want down a score in the 4th quarter?"  It's not like he's bad now -- I'm still glad he's the Steelers' quarterback -- but his resume is increasingly filled with "what ifs?" and "this one's on me."  What's most frustrating about all of this is that despite the two Super Bowls he already has, he is the only reason that he doesn't have more.

Remember the three picks in the 2004 AFC title game? Remember these stats from 2006: 75.4 QB rating, 18 TDs, 23 interceptions, 8-8 record?  Remember the three picks in the wild card loss to the Jaguars?  Remember the five game losing streak and no playoffs in 2009? (Yes, Dennis Dixon lost one of those games).  Remember that the six games Roethlisberger lost in 2009 were decided by 3, 3, 6, 3, 3, and 7 points? Remember the heinous pick-6 against the Packers in a Super Bowl the Steelers lost by 6 points?  Remember the horribly discombobulated 2-minute drill the Steelers butchered at the end of that game?  Remember the three sacks he took on the final 4th-quarter drive against Denver in last year's playoff game that kept the Steelers from getting in field goal range?  And remember the game-losing plays this year to Denver, Dallas, and now Cincinnati?

And remember this?
And remember this press conference?
And remember this press conference?
There's arguably an excuse for every one of these games -- injuries, bad offensive line, "he put them in a position to be there in the first place" -- but the fact remains that the negatives are adding up.  Two Super Bowls is potentially a hall-of-fame career, and even the best QBs don't win the Super Bowl every year.  But the "he left plays on the field" cliche is ever more applicable to Roethsliberger.  The Steelers will only go as far as he takes them.  Unfortunately, he limits himself.

None of this is meant to denigrate what he has accomplished, which is incredibly impressive.  It's just to say that no longer does the conversation about his legacy begin and end with "That guy's a winner."  It may still begin that way, but there's a "but."

- Obviously, the Steelers shouldn't trade Roethlisberger for Kirk Cousins, or anyone for that matter.  That's something we call the "Recoil Test" -- the best measure of a player's worth is your gut reaction to suggestions for trading him.  And I threw up on myself typing that headline.  So, yes, let's keep Ben.

- The Steelers' defense was very good yesterday.  We thought all along that the defense would be the downfall of this team.  What a shame that it now seems like another year of a good defense wasted.

- Having said that, like the playoff loss to Jacksonville 5 years ago, maybe this loss is a blessing in disguise.  Going 7-9 is a lot less damaging to the team's legacy than losing 45-14 in New England in the first round of the playoffs would have been.

- We will break down all the implications of the Steelers loss on tonight's podcast.  Make sure to watch for it.


Monday, October 22, 2012

GTOG Recap: Steelers Win 24-17. Also, What's Up With Andy Dalton's Hair?

By GTOG Staff

When the Steelers found themselves in a 14-3 hole to the Bengals last night after an historically awful dropped pass by Barron Batch, an inexcusable interception by Ben, and a classic BenFumble ("Bumble") after he tried to re-cock his arm with 4 guys pulling him to the ground, there were two schools of thought: 1) this so-called mediocre team is outright bad, or 2) this so-called mediocre team is still mediocre so be patient and let's not forget we're playing the Bengals.  Thankfully the second school of thought prevailed and we're right back to where we were at the beginning of the game: the Steelers are an OK team in the thick of an OK conference with only one team that might be more than OK (Houston).  There are worse places to be.

Worse place to be.
There is a lot of talk in Pittsburgh on Monday about how once Andy Dalton bounced the ball into Lamar Woodley's chest Lamarr Woodley stepped up and picked off Andy Dalton, the defense completely shut the door on the Bengals. We saw a different game. We saw a game where Cincinnati inexplicably refused to challenge Ike Taylor. We saw a game where, if you look at the defensive box score, YOU DON'T EVEN SEE JAMES HARRISON'S NAME.  We saw a game where James Harrison appeared completely disinterested in making contact with people.  We saw a game where James Harrison would have run to the sideline after every play to collect partial payment if he could.  We saw a game where Cincinnati - sweet, dependable Cincinnati - inexplicably ran twice right behind the back-up center right into the folds of Casey Hampton's all-encompassing flesh with the game on the line. We saw a game where Casey Hampton immediately ran to the sideline to swallow two whole oxygen tanks.

That doesn't mean we played good defense. It means we played at Paul Brown Stadium.

Worse place to be.
Find out the real reason the Steelers won after the jump...


- At GTOG, there are really only three governing principles: 1) life is a journey, so call it that; 2) don't tell Artistry how to be a father; and 3) hair matters.  And never has hair mattered more than last night.

You can look break down all the stats you want and criticize Bengals ownership til you're tiger-striped in the face, but the real reason this current crop of Bengals can't compete with the Steelers is simple: Andy Dalton's hair.


It's not that we have anything against red heads.  We don't.  It's just that, well, all of it.  Look at that hair!


Whatever confidence you may have in his physical abilities, the fact that he has that hair yet actively chooses not to shave his head is irresponsible and disqualifies him from ever winning a Super Bowl.  He just doesn't pass the test of looking like a quarterback, and it's all the hair.  Give that hair to any other quarterback and you'd feel the same way.





You get the point.

- You can't accuse the Steelers of not wishing Mike Wallace was worth Larry Fitzgerald money. They threw to him 15 times on Sunday. He caught 8 of those passes for 52 yards. For the sake of comparison, since Wallace asked for it, this study shows Larry Fitzgerald only drops about 3% of catchable passes thrown his way. Wallace's drop percentage is just a touch higher, is it not?

- The Steelers are back to their old ways of giving up long kick returns, even if the returns originate deep in the end zone. And they can't set up a punt return of their own without holding somebody. They should just call for a fair catch and subtract ten yards.  Can we address this special teams situation? Hold a moment. We're now getting reports that the Mike Tomlin already fired a perfectly acceptable special teams coach like 7 weeks ago. Let's just move on.

- It's time to update the Steelers nickname list.  We have 1st-and-30 (Willie Colon), Gay Island (William Gay), Second-and-9 (Isaac Redman), Ben (Ben), Key (Key) and Dozens of Torn Triceps Are Not Indicative of Steroid Use (Aaron Smith).  This week we propose "Booty Call" for Ryan Mundy: he's never your first choice and you're constantly auditioning other people for the role, but he's always there when you call on him yet it's never as satisfying as you hope.

Booty Call.
- Wait until Heinz Field sees RGIII. The Steelers will need 30 points to win.

- Here are a couple of things Todd Haley has exactly right: 1) The Steelers have to get Antonio Brown as many touches as possible; and 2) They need to control the ball. Dink, dunk, dash, dip. Whatever you need to do. We can't count on the defense to stop a team with a great QB from getting points 3 out of 4 trips down the field.

- You think we're overstating how bad the defense is? We're at the very top of the league on offense in terms of third down conversion percentage. We're top 3 in time of possession. And we still aren't a scary team to play against.

- For those of you who have either forgotten, don't want to think about, or just never experienced the days of Bubby Brister, Mark Malone, Cliff Stoudt, and Kent Graham, et al., take a minute every game to point two fingers to the sky for Ben Roethlisberger. The fact that we feel like facing 3rd and 6 multiple times in a drive and converting every time is no biggie is more than remarkable. It's astounding. And it's all Ben.

- All praise to the offensive line. Band of Brothers.


Monday, September 17, 2012

GTOPG: Ben Being Ben; Steelers Win 27-10

By Finesse

Make no mistake about it.  Sunday's win over the Jets was a huge win because it proved two things: the defense is still capable of shutting down mediocre quarterbacks and the Todd Haley quick passing game means more Good Ben and less Bad Ben.

First, the defense.  It wasn't a dominating performance and early on it looked like we were on the verge of spending the season watching one of the most unlikeable defenses in Steelers' history (that sentiment is based solely on Ike Taylor's "coverage" on the Santonio Holmes touchdown).  But in a league where a 14 point lead with more than 5 minutes remaning in a game is essentially meaningless, only giving up 10 points is a significant accomplishment.

As for the offense, it was, as usual, all about Ben.  For better or worse, Ben is Ben but anyone who watches Ben knows that the statement "Ben is Ben" doesn't tell you which Ben you're getting because Ben can be Good Ben or Ben can be Bad Ben but either way, Ben is Ben.  Ben is always Ben.  Ben loved B.A. because B.A. didn't care whether he was getting Good Ben or Bad Ben, only that he was letting Ben be Ben.  Haley, on the other hand, appears determined to harness Good Ben and minimize Bad Ben, all while still letting Ben be Ben.  Because the truth is, no matter what anyone does, Ben will be Ben.

Ben being Ben in bare feet.
Ben was a masterful 24-31 for 275 yards, 2 touchdowns, and three good-sacks.  And for the second straight week he was an artist on 3rd down, converting 8 of 15 attempts (after 11 of 19 last week).   That's important because Second-and-9 and Jonathan Dwyer were, again, wildly ineffective for most of the game.   Second-and-9 had 12 carries for 25 yards, but if you throw out his 13 yard run, he was a Chris Johnson-esque 11 carries for 12 yards.  You could average more rushing yards by fumbling the snap on every play.

The running game is a big concern, but the severe decree of our judgment is tempered because it is Rosh Hashana and because the Steelers are being patient about it and aren't giving up on running.  Forget the total yards -- it's the 28 attempts that matter, because 28 rushing attempts means Ben only needs to try to get 7 yards on 3rd-and-6 instead of 15 yards on every 1st-and-10.  That's a leaner, more efficient Big Ben.  And a lean, efficient Big Ben is huge.

So lean. So efficient.
More thoughts after the jump...


- The 2012 Steelers season may be more dependent on Ike Taylor than any of us are comfortable with.  We're close to a comical level of passing in the NFL -- Eli Manning threw for 510 yards Sunday and it's unclear whether he even had a good game (he threw 3 picks).  That means that Ike is going to be swaggin' into your living room about 30 times a game from here on out.

- Speaking of Ike, the pass interference call against him for being close to Ryan Clark maybe delivering a late hit on Santonio was so bad that it immediately became funny and made me sympathetic toward the replacement officials.  They're like tongueless kids taking the Pepsi Challenge: there's dribble all over their chest and no one understands what they're saying, but they look really cute.

- As great as the defense was in the final 3 quarters, I'm going to hold off on declaring that the Steel Curtain is back until they do it against a quarterback who isn't so dumb he thought it was a better idea to date Eva Longoria than Kate Upton.  Sanchize was 10-27 for 138 yards.  Eli Manning had 138 yards in one drive on Sunday.

So similar. But so different.
- Does Santonio Holmes call for a flag every time he stands up? When he gets out of bed in the morning, does he immediately wave his hand in the air and look around for a flag?  What about when he gets out of the car?  Can he do it with a joint in his hand?

- Once again, Drew Butler was majestic with the ball on his foot.  The guy puts punts inside the 20 like it's his job.  My current MVP ballot:

5. Patrick Peterson
4. Drew Butler
3. Alex Smith
2. Matt Ryan
1. Brandon "Guaranteed W"eeden

- The Steelers have not yet established themselves as anything more than one of the many above-mediocre teams in the AFC.  But the trend line is back to positive.


Friday, September 7, 2012

GTOG 2012 AFC Preview, as told by Huffington Post Women

By Finesse

It's that time of year again where we try to think of things to say about football teams we don't pay that much attention to.  That's right, it's NFL Preview time.  This year, our preview is through the lens of one of the most consistently fascinating yet baffling web pages on all the interent: The Huffington Post's Women's page.  These are all real headlines from the last week.

At my side to guide me through this preview is my hard-copy 84-page Yahoo! Sports Fantasy Football Draft Kit, of which 54% of American males have a printed copy, but only 36% admit to having printed at work despite the fact that only 11% of American males have printers in their homes.  Let's get right to it.

NEW YORK JETS


Like whoever wrote this headline, the Jets appear to have no idea what they are doing.  They gave Mark Sanchez a three-year contract extension this March, which would be sensible if you could win Super Bowls for dating Kate Upton which, arguably, you should be able to do.  But then they signed Tim Tebow, giving them the dangerous 1-2 punch of the 25th best starter in the league and 17th best backup.  The Jets are the steroids of the NFL -- the media cares about them way more than the rest of us do.

PREDICTION: 8-8

OAKLAND RAIDERS



No.
Prediction: 8-8

Much, much more after the jump...


MIAMI DOLPHINS


Hey girl, forget Sanchez-Tebow, the biggest question coming out of the preseason is who is America's next sweetheart -- Les Brown's wife or Ryan Tennehill's wife?


Same neckline as Gosling's shirt.
If I told you that the guy whose wife lost that competition in a landslide is going to be the starting rookie quarterback on a team that went 0-4 in the preseason and got outscored 96-43, is there any chance you wouldn't take the under on their current over/under of 7 total wins?

Prediction: 5-11.

CLEVELAND BROWNS


According to my Draft Kit depth chart, the Browns are starting a rookie quarterback (Brandon Weeden), a rookie running back (Trent Richardson), and they are the Browns (Cleveland).  If you don't know what this is a recipe for, let's let the Draft Kit do the talking:
Weeden's rookie year figures to be ugly.  The 22nd overall pick will be throwing to the league's worst receivers in the league's toughest defensive division, and he'll get four games against the NFC East, too, which may be the second-toughest defensive division.
I'm sold.

Prediction: 3-13.

NEW ENGLAND


With a lot of teams which are hated by the masses (ok, not a lot, just the Miami Heat), public opinion tends to eventually sway back to a point where the former villains become semi-liked because they "deserve" to win.  Not so with the Patriots.  Everyone I know has hated them, continues to hate them, and will hate them well into the future.  Coincidentally, that's the same way Bill Belichik feels about orgasms.

"They don't do it for me."
Prediction: 13-3.

SAN DIEGO CHARGERS

You guys, in last year's preview, we picked San Diego to represent the AFC in the Super Bowl.  They still have Antonio Gates, who will forever be a nemesis to Pittsburgh after the 2002 NCAA Tournament, and they still have Philip Rivers who, just like last year, fits perfectly into both the redemption and the "it's his time" narratives.  For the first year in a long time the Chargers aren't seen as one of the favorites in the AFC -- that's a good thing for them.

PREDICTION: 11-5

JACKSONVILLE JAGUARS


Like the NFL deciding to NOT move the Jags out of Jacksonville as soon as possible, Keltie Colleen is NOT afraid to make the tough decisions.  In addition to NOT having a bridal party, she has also chosen to NOT bring a bottle of wine to a friend's dinner party and NOT wipe off her mat after hot yoga.  Maurice Jones-Drew, on the other hand, chose NOT to report to training camp on time and, therefore, will NOT be in a lot of people's fantasy football lineup in Week 1.  I'm NOT going to pretend like I know anything about the Jaguars.

Prediction: 7-9.

DENVER BRONCOS


When the Broncos dumped Tim Tebow for Peyton Manning, it was as bold as a Bachelor looking Chris Harrison in the eye and saying, "I want to cancel the cocktail party. I know what I want to do."  Huge chance of a backfire here, so let's go to the Yahoo! Draft Kit depth chart and think worst-case scenario.  If they have a rash of injuries on offense (if God smites them), this is who they will trot out: Caleb Hannie, Ronnie Hillman, Xavier Jaffe, Matthew Willis, and Jacob Tamme.  One of those people is fake.  Don't mess with God.

Prediction: 6-10.

BUFFALO BILLS


Even after Ann Romney declared her love for YOUUUU WOMMMENNNN, I will assume this offer isn't "put your money where your mouth is" and not click it.  The Bills have some relevance this year, as they were OK last year when My Boy Fred Jackson was tearing up the league until he broke his leg.  Let's hope the same doesn't happen to Ann Romney's horse.

That was inappropriate.
Prediction: 10-6.

BALTIMORE RAVENS

This story reminds me of a guy I know who almost committed suicide but then discovered Blue Tub and ended up starting Google.

Game changer.
It also reminds me of Joe Flacco's eyebrows, which then remind me that Joe Flacco is actually a good quarterback who threw a perfect pass under pressure that should have taken the Ravens to the Super Bowl last year.  Unfortunately he threw it to Lee Evans.  This year, according to my Draft Kit depth chart, Lee Evans is not one of the top 3 receivers on Baltimore.  Torrey Smith is, however, and he's a beast.

Prediction: 12-4

PITTSBURGH STEELERS


Nothing says Labor Day like hard hats and lunch pails, and nothing says hard hats and lunch pails like a team led by its two captains, Ben and Key.  But when Ben and Key lead their Men out of that tunnel onto the field of battle, it won't be about the inspirational quotes.

"There's a fine line between drinking wine and squashing grapes."
It will be about the leadership of Ben, and the reviews are mixed.  On the one hand, he has 3 Super Bowl appearances, a phenomenal winning percentage and ACLs that refuse to snap.  But on the other hand, after almost every game (even the wins), I'm left feeling like he should have been better.  When you watch Brady, Brees and Rodgers, you rarely say to yourself, "What the hell is he doing?!?!?"  With Ben?  At least ten times a game.

This is not to say that I'm not happy with Ben as the Steelers' QB.  But it does mean that for better or worse, the Steelers go as far as Ben takes them.  It's just always too hard to say how far that will be.

Prediction: 10-6.

TENNESSEE TITANS


I am over 25 and I don't know much, but I do know that you shouldn't spend $51 on Chris Johnson in an auction draft when Tom Brady is going for $47, Matt Forte for $36, and My Boy Fred Jackson for $26.  Speaking of fantasy drafts, Artistry is attempting to become the first person to win a fantasy football league with two white starting WRs.  He should name his team "Lerone, Will You Accept This Rose?"


PREDICTION: 6-10

HOUSTON TEXANS

Here's the biggest question about the Texans going into this season: Are the two women in this picture smiling because mammograms are that fun or did they just share a good old-fashioned mammogram joke?

Doctor: What kind of bees produce milk?
Patient: I don't know, what?
Doctor: Boobies!!!

It's really not the smiles that are the most disturbing thing about this picture -- it's the attempt at eye contact by the doctor during the exam.  This would be like my doctor saying to me during a prostate exam, "turn around and look me in the eye."

Anyway, the Texans are getting tons of Super Bowl buzz, but there are two reasons why they won't make the Super Bowl: 1) Andre Johnson's hamstrings; and 2) because they let the consensus-worst-pick-ever-who-turned-out-to-be-the-consensus-best-pick-ever, Mario Williams, sign with Buffalo.

PREDICTION: 11-5

CINCINNATI BENGALS


Like this woman's apartment, the Bengals have recently gone from crappy to a little less crappy and almost no one cares.  The worst part about the Bengals' ascent back into relevance is the prospect of the Steelers trying to cover A.J. Green for the next decade.  It will get ugly.

PREDICTION: 8-8

KANSAS CITY CHIEFS


Of all the headlines, this is the only one that I couldn't resist clicking.  To summarize:

An associate professor at Texas A&M University kidnapped 150 students and made them watch the following shows: 7th Heaven, Gilmore Girls, The Tudors, Masters of Horror, Buffy the Vampire Slayer and Law and Order: SVU.  Those who survived were asked a bunch of questions and the results were Martin-Luterian in their challenge to traditional orthodoxy.  As a professor from the University of Washington, who may or may not have been involved in the study, reported to Huffington Post: United Kingdom, "I think this points to the importance of strong women role models, both in real life and in fictional media, and how important these role models are for both men and women, or boys and girls."

What does this have to do with the Chiefs?  Nothing, yet everything.

In 2010, the Browns traded Peyton Hillis to Denver for Brady Quinn.  They are now the backup quarterback and backup running back on Kansas City.

Could have used a little more accuracy and a little less BUFFY.
Prediction: 9-7.

INDIANAPOLIS COLTS

From the author of "How Brushing My Teeth Makes my Mouth Feel Clean" and "Why Shoes That Fit Feel Better Than Shoes That Don't," Elizabeth Dosoretz brings you the epic tale of that Saturday afternoon where she finally threw away those tops she never wears and felt so ..... INVIGORATED!

Same goes for the Colts and Peyton Manning.  Discarding Manning was like Elizabeth discarding her favorite top: she felt awful about it, but it could no longer conceal the flaws it used to conceal.  No matter how sensible of a move it was -- and it was sensible -- it's sad to see Manning go to another team.  But those are the breaks, and the Colts caught a big one getting Luck at #1.

PREDICTION: An invigorated 6-10.

Monday, March 19, 2012

Big Ben's Barracks: Ben wants the Steelers to trade for Tim Tebow

By GTOG Staff and Big Ben

After news broke this morning that Peyton Manning intends to sign with the Denver Broncos, Ben Roethlisberger began working feverishly to ensure the Steelers enter the inevitable Tim Tebow sweepstakes. GTOG obtained an exclusive transcript of Ben's conversation with his agent, Ryan Tollner. Let's listen in after the jump...



Ben: I want to lead Tim Tebow.  I need you to call Mr. Rooney and see if he can get Tim Tebow to Pittsburgh.

Agent: Really? To compete for your job?

Ben: He's a great Man.  I don't want to compete with him.  I want to lead him.

Agent: But isn't he also a Leader of Men?

Ben: He does lead Men. I've watched how he leads Men, and I'm impressed with his ability to lead Men.

Agent: Right, that's what I don't get?

Ben: I am the Leader of Men here in Pittsburgh, and I'd like him to follow me.

"I will be answering no more questions about Following Me."
Agent: I don't know about that, Ben.  He's a devoted Leader of Men.  What if there aren't enough
Men in Pittsburgh to be led?

Ben: Every Man needs a Leader, but not every Leader needs a Man.

Agent: I don't understand what that means.

Ben: Because you don't lead Men.

Agent: Can you two lead each other?

Ben: I can't be led. I lead.

Agent: But will he be able to lead and follow at the same time?

Ben: One of the hallmarks of a great Leader is that he knows when to follow a great Leader.

Agent: But you just said that Leaders don't follow.

Ben: I'm leading you right now.

"Follow me."
Agent: Ok. Look, I can call Mr. Rooney, but I don't think the Steelers will have interest.

Ben: Let me tell you a story. One time a Leader approached a Man and said, "Do you want to be led?"  The Man said he didn't know what it was to be led.  And the Leader said, "But you have just been led."

Agent: Wait, what?

Ben: I've just led you.

Agent: Led me where?

Ben: Here.

Agent: Wasn't I already here?

Ben: You were here, but you were not led here.  I led you here.

Agent: Right. So how will you lead Tebow?

Ben: Like I lead all my Men.

Agent: But he's not just any Man.

Ben: I'm not just any Leader.

Agent: What will your guys think?

Ben: My guys are my guys.

Agent: What position do you think he'll play?

Ben: That's up to God and B.A.

Agent: B.A. was fired.

Ben: Like the Bible and my civil litigation, B.A. is eternal.

Agent: Ben, I think you lost me.

Ben: Shh. Follow me.

Too many Leaders, not enough Men.


Monday, March 5, 2012

Tebow approached to be "The Bachelor;" Would father baby without help of Fantasy Suite

It's more likely that Ben Roethlisberger would be the Bachelor before Tim Tebow would enter the Fantasy Suite with one of these ladies, but it's a fun thought nonetheless. Also, no way Tebow would be insurable for the Broncos with all those helicopter rides.

Want to know how else Big Ben and Tebow compare? Click here for the GTOG tale of the tape...



Sunday, January 8, 2012

GTOG Raw Emotion Podcast: Tebow Eliminates Steelers; Have Penguins Hit Rock Bottom?

These are turbulent times, but instead of docking at any port in the storm, come to GTOG. We start by talking about the Steelers-Broncos and ask where Ike Taylor's performance ranks historically and how much blame Roethlisberger should take. We then get into the Penguins' Ridiculous Injury Situation Part 2, the Crosby uncertainty, and whether management should -- or can -- do anything. Finally, of course, the Bachelor. These are emotional times. Experience them with us. It's the GTOG Podcast.

Click here to subscribe on iTunes

For iPad/iPhone:


Podcast Powered By Podbean

For Flash devices: